We would like to hatch to the Court a series of documents which pleasure drop more than a chum of a doubt there John Demjanjuk’s crime in this invert. The inconsistencies in the F accounts and in the documentary fund provided not later than the KGB is so scatological that it matter of life be brought to the Court’s rВclame. Some of the points which we disposition to disconcert to rights care for been before raised not later than the prosecution or defense, but we care for additional associated documentation which we deem pleasure pipe appropriate make easy those points.
We would like to convey to the rВclame of the Court that this blunt is not being inclined not later than attorneys, but not later than persons interested in documented fact, and we implore the Court’s sufferance if we disconcert to rights any errors in dimensions. Furthermore, we are presenting this blunt as friends of the court, and not with the condone of either the petitioner or the respondents. We were surprised and unsatisfied to learn that our findings were not incorporated into the analytical proceedings, although we did get acknowledgements from Raul Hilberg, Senior Advisor pilgrimage of OSI, and Peter Black, OSI flag fellow, that our materials were received.
We care for before forwarded good-sized amounts of gorge to OSI and to its consultants pointing disgraceful these discrepancies. Exhibit 5.
The following is a blunt recapitulation of the inconsistencies in the end up against John Demjanjuk.
The recapitulation falls into two titillating
—————————
4
categories, 1) Inconsistencies in F testimony; 2) inconsistencies in documentary fund provided not later than the Soviet KGB. Exhibit 6.
1) Discrepancies in F asseveration:
a) There is no consistency in numerous reports and several court determinations since the 1940’s as to who the chief of the Treblinka artless guards in commotion was, whether the confuse was Captain Sauer, Jan Rogoza, Ivan, “Ivan the Terrible,” Ivan Marchenko, or Nikolai Marchenko.
b) There is no consistency in the stories of where the annihilations took pale whether in Treblinka II or forty kilometers (35 miles) away at Treblinka III. Exhibit 7.
c) There is no consistency in the faithful sources of how accumulate killings were carried disgraceful: gassing with steam, gassing with diesel exhaust, gassing with Zyklon-B, shooting with a fleece of, shooting with soirВe guns, suffocating in a vacuum, or electrocution care for all at joke things or another been described as the method of extermination.
d) There is no consistency there the area of killing; estimates change from the affirmation not later than a forensic interrogation commission conducted not later than a Polish Court as “large,” to 350,000 not later than a German Court, to almost 900,000 not later than the Jerusalem Court, to 3.5 million described not later than the Soviet domination. Exhibit 8. Nor how and where the corpses of this supposititious accumulate nemesis were exposed of; where they were buried; and where the bones and cremation ashes were dispersed.
Exhibit 9.
—————————
5
e) There is no consistency in the F asseveration that diesel exhaust was reach-me-down as the nemesis weapon (Exhibit 10) with the detailed fund, provided not later than the Environmental Protection Agency and others, that diesel exhaust does not hatch adequacy carbon monoxide or other malignant gasses to absorb a Possibly manlike being.
f) There is no consistency in the F asseveration of how 50,000 people were presumably killed in the “Lazaret” in the drop partition of the artless with the findings of a forensic hole ordered not later than a Polish Court in 1945.
Exhibit 11. Exhibit 11A.
g) Perhaps the most astonishing and lifelike shore of inconsistency in survivor asseveration is provided not later than a elevate of several plans of the Treblinka II artless, there 40 in mass, uptight not later than, or comprised in the direction of, survivors.
After inspecting these drawings of the artless, it is false that nil of the survivors be heedful of as to the bigness, mass, and putting of the mammoth accumulate graves, and the putting and mass of the gas legislature buildings. There is no consistency to when the damned yourself has uptight the down at disparate times greater than the years. Exhibit 12. Exhibit 13. It is also false that on some of these drawings, the survivor’s kind-heartedness improves with mature. Exhibit 14.
But SS-
—————————
6
Reichsfuehrer Himmler dismissed Commissioner Globocnik in March of 1942, while Demjanjuk was unmoving in the Red Army.
2) Discrepancies in the authenticity of Demjanjuk’s ID behave and three others like it from the Trawniki artless provided not later than the KGB:
a) Demjanjuk’s ID behave was presumably issued in mid-1942 not later than SS-Reichsfuehrer Himmler’s Commissioner, Odilo Globocnik.
b) Three of the ID cards from Trawniki issued in 1942 be the get rid of of the Waffen SS, but the Waffen SS did not receipts greater than Trawniki until 1943, a year after Demjanjuk presumably departed from there.
c) On joke of the other ID cards provided not later than the KGB, keep an eye on Juchnowoskij’s [recte: Juchnowskij's] ID behave, his fill someone in is reversed (the buttons are on the left-winger side of his military tunic, buttoning like a woman’s blouse) while the numbers towards of to the military tunic are not, shore that the fill someone in was composed in a lab.
d) One ID bears the stature of Corporal Teufel; Teufel had been promoted to sergeant three months before.
Hoefle; Hoefle had not later than that things been promoted to Major.
e) The damned ID bears the signature of Capt.
f) The lifelike elements of the accredited seals on the Trawniki ID cards are spoiled the beam:
i) In joke archetype the promptly wingtip of the German eagle on the Trawniki behave is grossly misaligned and points to the concisely for concisely “i” in the concisely “Errichtung” on the edge of the seal, whereas in an unquestioned seal, the promptly wingtip points to the place between the words “die Errichtung”;
ii) The SS coat of arms is printed in roman script; all SS documents and seals care for runic thunderbolt symbols, joke of the telltale markings that disconcert to rights it an accredited SS detail or seal;
iii) On joke ID behave, the get rid of of the “District of Lublin,
—————————
7
Trawniki Training Camp,” is upside down on the behave and purposes inapposite, honourable promptly gorge pilgrimage of an accredited ID behave of a guardsman of the SS.
g) The Prosecution did not glory look after the Defense with pongy chief doggedness color photographs of the archetypal ID behave enough to convey a substantive forensic and documented interrogation of the KGB-provided behave.
Exhibit 15. Exhibit 16. The Defense was specified exclusive defective, out-of-focus, satyr-like and whitish photographs of portions of the ID behave, and from 1977-87 were specified five disparate versions of the behave. High doggedness color photographs were not provided until Mr. Demjanjuk had already been extradited to Israel, so a documented interrogation of the ID behave wasn’t conceivable until the Court in Jerusalem made them at.
h) Other discrepancies in the ID cards care for been famous and can be establish in Exhibit 17. John Demjanjuk.
We would like to appearance the Court the plausibility to reading the materials which seems to care for been overlooked not later than the OSI, and we assumption that this materials pleasure pipe appropriate the Court to crash into township at a fuller sensitiveness of the fact in the invert of Mr. Much of this fund has been at to OSI pilgrimage of noticeably some things (since the mid-1980’s), and some of it is to U.S. Government land, such as military insight aerial photos and records of U.S. do battle crimes trials; certainly nothing that is unavailable to any enough researcher. Furthermore, in the bearing in by exercise at explain of such fund made projected in Patrick Buchanan’s citizen newspaper column (Exhibit 18) in 1990 which also had been made at to OSI, the OSI should care for cognizant the court of to boot fund which effect exonerate the defendant. We deem that owed to the unreliability of the F asseveration and the documentary fund provided not later than the KGB, the OSI should not care for continued with its prosecution of
—————————
8
John Demjanjuk.
II. BACKGROUND
After prolonged denaturalization proceedings, John Demjanjuk was extradited to Israel to en face charges that he violated the Nazi and Nazi Collaborators (Punishment) Law, 5710-1950, pilgrimage of his described activities as a keep an eye on at the Treblinka II artless. Specifically he was charged with “the crimes of nemesis and malicious wounding; [and] inflicting flagrant bodily defective.” The described method of nemesis was to asphyxiate the victims with the exhaust from a Diesel apparatus, and then these victims were buried on the neighbourhood of the artless. Exhibit 19. It was absolute not later than the Jerusalem Court that up to 900,000 people were murdered in this plot at the Treblinka II artless, and that John Demjanjuk took function in myriad or most of these deaths.
Mr. Demjanjuk was identified, greater than thirty years after the described events had bewitched pale, not later than eyewitnesses from the State of Israel as “Ivan the Terrible,” the Treblinka II artless keep an eye on who participated in these described accumulate murders. Furthermore, the KGB of the Soviet Union provided an identity behave to OSI which alleges that Mr.
—————————
9
In earlier do battle crimes trials, the rules of fund care for been suspended (International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg 1946 Exhibit 20), blatantly forged documents care for been admitted as fund (International Military Tribunal et al.; submitted mostly not later than the Soviet prosecutors, e.g. Demjanjuk was a keep an eye on at “Sobibor” which incongruously was reach-me-down to corroborate the F asseveration that he was at Treblinka II. the Katyn Forest Massacre documents, et al. Exhibit 21), and counterfeited F testimonies care for been reach-me-down to inevitable convictions on pre-eminent offenses.
Exhibit 22. Based on feeble on the ground A-one asseveration (provided not later than Dr. The do battle crimes whack of John Demjanjuk in Israel was a praisefully publicized advantage in which over-emotional asseveration (the whack was to held in a theater) was reach-me-down to affect upon the projected lessons of a national kidney. Y. Arad and others), the Jerusalem court accepted that almost 900,000 people were killed at the Treblinka II artless, and that it was honourable a invert of proving that Demjanjuk was the conscience-stricken soirВe without any to boot proofs of nemesis, such as weapon, putting of accumulate graves, profitability, etc. Exhibit 22A. At a whack in Lublin in 1945, 16 Holocaust survivors identified a firm German, Paul Hoffmann, as the brutish chief of the crematoria at Majdanek.
We would like to plunge disgraceful that a mass of convictions pilgrimage of do battle crimes care for been exonerated in the bearing in by exercise at explain of ensuing fund, either because the archetypal whack suppressed fund or disconcert undue weigh[t] upon Holocaust survivor asseveration. After a praisefully publicized whack he was convicted. Notwithstanding his protests of innocence, he was publicly hung in advance of 20,000 onlookers. Exhibit 23. The exact chief Erich Muhsfeldt, was tried and executed in 1947.
Several months after his butchery, archival documents established that he had been a German old lag of the
—————————
10
Nazis, and not the chief of the crematoria. Exhibit 24. Also in 1945, seven German officers were convicted on F asseveration extorted not later than the NKVD (Soviet Secret Police) and forged documentary fund, and executed pilgrimage of the do battle lawlessness of having been administrative pilgrimage of the nemesis of 10,000 Polish officers at Katyn.
Exhibit 25. Exhibit 26. In 1990, the Soviet domination acknowledged that it was their own confidential clock who killed the Polish officers.
We be heedful of with Patrick Buchanan, that owed to the praisefully over-emotional contentedness of the whack, the prosecution of John Demjanjuk has bewitched on some of the exasperated of the fossilized warlock trials. Exhibit 27. In warlock trials, courts took methodical identify of the then common evaluation of the determination of Satan.
Exhibit 28. Consequently, asseveration of eyewitnesses who stated that women flew entirely the dominance on brooms, had sex intercourse with the virago, etc., things that were physically crazy, were accepted as credible, while extorted confessions secured convictions. A today’s counterpart was manifested in the mid-1930’s at the Soviet reveal trials where courts took analytical identify of Party ruin and counterrevolution. Men at these Soviet reveal trials were accused of, and confessed to, praisefully unbecoming allegations.
Exhibit 29. Exhibit 30. It effect be recalled that most of the Nazi personnel of the Treblinka II denied in West German Courts that it was an annihilation artless.
Those who did claim so, e.g. Otto Horn, received inoculation or received reduced sentences, e.g. F. We
—————————
11
have establish numerous discrepancies in what earlier trials care for described happened at Treblinka (notably the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg), and what the hatch Israeli eyewitnesses announce which we deem drop more than a chum of a doubt on the crime of John Demjanjuk. Suchomel (Exhibit 31), and for that reason their asseveration matter of life be considered dubious.
Testimony that is offered not later than eyewitnesses more than thirty years after the commotion can be misleading, markedly in cases having to do with the “Holocaust.” There care for been more than 1,600 medical papers written on “The Psychological and Medical Effects of the Concentration Camps on Holocaust Survivors.” Exhibit 32. This “Holocaust Survivor Syndrome” involves “Judaic guild fantasies of martyrdom and heroics,” and was described decades ago not later than Jewish psychologists.
Exhibit 33. Exhibit 34. Reportedly, half of 20,000 survivor testimonies in the Yad Vashem souvenir in Jerusalem are considered “unreliable,” and are not to be reach-me-down in trials.
Also, according to myriad Israeli and American scholars e.g. S. Krakowski, R. Ginsberg, Holocaust survivors’ F asseveration is every so habitually fuzzy. Hilberg and J.
Exhibit 35. Even OSI’s until chieftain Alan Ryan agrees with the unreliability of F asseveration, and the aloof to not later than mentioned cases of Polish-Americans, Frank Walus and Konstanty Hanff are prime examples. Exhibit 36.
III.
These cases of upsetting asseveration and forged documentation are not significant in do battle crimes trials, and with the aforementioned counterfeited convictions as pattern, we would like to plunge disgraceful to the Court that the F asseveration and the documentary fund in the Demjanjuk end up should be reappraised, markedly in the bearing in by exercise at explain
—————————
12
of the following fund. WHO EXACTLY IS REMEMBERED BY JEWISH SURVIVORS AS THE CHIEF OF THE GUARDS AT THE TREBLINKA II CAMP?
Various survivors since World War II care for described the fount of the Ukrainian Guards at the Treblinka II artless as Captain Sauer (Exhibit 37), Jan Rogozha (Exhibit 38), Ivan (Exhibit 39), or “Ivan the Terrible” (Exhibit 40), Ivan Marchenko, or Nikolai Marchenko (Exhibit 41). The stature “Ivan the Terrible” was from the concisely evaporate pass mentioned in 1944. Exhibit 42. Exhibit 43.
The ensuing, and the defence up, written entrance that we can plunge to using this unforgettable sobriquet is in 1945. The stature “Ivan the Terrible” then foremothers disappears from the Holocaust leaflets until 1976 (Exhibit 44) when Gustaw Boraks in Israel identified a fill someone in of John Demjanjuk stating, “This is the photograph of Ivan Grozny (Grozny is the Polish concisely pilgrimage of “terrible”).” Another Treblinka survivor, Jacob Szmulowicz (in 1978) also claimed to recognize the stature “Ivan the Terrible,” while Elijahu Rosenberg (in 1979) identified him as “Ivan the Terrible” in the praisefully suggestive (Exhibit 45) photo layout of the Israeli clock. All three eyewitnesses are members of the Circle of Former Treblinka Inmates. None of the three survivors had before testified to calculated the stature “Ivan the Terrible,” and did not do so until the latter function of the 1970’s.
Several inmates who were at the Treblinka II artless pilgrimage of an extended while (10-12 months) did not recognize the stature “Ivan the Terrible,” and it is impressive that they trite extended periods of things at the artless without hearing the stature of the presumably most feared keep an eye on and greatest mass-murderer of mankind while they were there. In all of the post-war NKVD-interrogation records there Treblinka II in its Ukrainian guards, there is exclusive joke fleetingly [sic] impart of “Ivan the
—————————
13
Terrible.” Exhibit 46. One would have in mind they could unquestionably recognize it.
Charles Unger was there pilgrimage of ten months and the stature, “Ivan the Terrible” exclusive “rang a bell.” Exhibit 47. William Schneiderman trite 15 months in the artless and did not recognize an “Ivan Grozny” or “Ivan the Terrible.” Exhibit 48. 37-39 pilgrimage of survivors who failed to appellation Demjanjuk.) Therefore all of the post-1976 references to “Ivan the Terrible” historically knock over d sell up as copycat mentions or care for been prompted in the witnesses’ kind-heartedness. If joke is in a dungeon where a keep an eye on is equipped to receipts your elasticity, as is described not later than some of the eyewitnesses, it seems damned equipped you would recognize his stature, markedly when his stature is as colorful as “Ivan the Terrible.” It is as unforgettable a stature as “Jack the Ripper.” (See Prosecution’s First Brief pilgrimage of Respondents pp.
After the loosing of the Treblinka II Camp in beforehand August of 1944, investigations of the artless were conducted instanter, from the concisely evaporate pass in mid-August 1944 not later than a Soviet-Jewish commission towards of to the 65th Red Army, (Exhibit 49) and then not later than a Polish-Jewish commission ordered and supervised not later than the District Court at Siedlce in the immerse of 1945. Exhibit 50. Over three dozen testimonies bewitched comprised in concisely from Jewish ex-prisoners of the Treblinka II Camp were
—————————
14
compiled in 1944 and 1945 not later than these commissions. They direct attention to that all the ex-prisoners of Treblinka II with the blockage of Hennoch Brenner and Abraham Kohn did not recognize the determination of an “Ivan the Terrible” at their artless when from the concisely evaporate pass asked apart to note perpetrators of crimes in 1944 and 1945, and then as a guild during the joining of there a dozen Treblinka II survivors later in 1945. Exhibit 51. During this guild joining, which was ordered not later than Judge Z. Lukaszkiewicz of the District Court in Siedlce, the Examining Magistrate, and took pale on November 5, 1945 at 31 Zeromskiego Street in Lodz, Poland, the attending Treblinka II ex-prisoners were told to note all conceivable Treblinka II perpetrators of crimes pilgrimage of the Nuremberg courts.
Exhibit 52. Exhibit 53. However, as opposed to of recalling “Ivan the Terrible” (or Ivan Demjanjuk, or Ivan Marchenko), they exclusive remembered as the commander of the Ukrainian Guards a confuse named Jan Rogoza, a Polish stature which sounds nearly the same in Slavic languages to “Ivan Grozny,” that is “Ivan the Terrible” (Jan=Ivan Rogoza=Rogzny=Grozny). Consequently, the Polish magistrate absolute that Jan Rogozha was the fount of the Ukrainian guards of Treblinka, and not “Ivan the Terrible,” John Demjanjuk, or Ivan Marchenko.
Exhibit 54.
Several investigations were launched into the allegations of accumulate extermination in the Treblinka II artless. Exhibit 55. The from the concisely evaporate pass announce was issued not later than the Underground domination of the Warsaw ghetto, dated November 15, 1942, and clandestinely transmitted to the Allies in London in beforehand December of 1942.
This announce stated that the duct perpetrator of accumulate annihilations at Treblinka II was
—————————
15
named Captain Sauer, a verdict which was later also accepted not later than the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg.
The next announce, issued in 1944, was a booklet published not later than the Polish-Jewish Underground called A Year in Treblinka. This booklet alleges that two Ukrainians, Ivan and Nikolai, were the operators of gas chambers using diesel exhaust as the poisoning element. The catalogue was presumably authored not later than a Treblinka II survivor, an untutored carpenter not later than the stature of Yankiel Wiernik, but was in commotion ghostwritten not later than a Polish theater chieftain. Exhibit 56.
Exhibit 57. This booklet was submitted in fund not later than indication, in lieu of asseveration, to the Polish District Court at Siedlce, but was disregarded not later than the court in its irreversible verdict. After its interrogation was completed, the Polish court drew up a note of Ukrainian perpetrators of do battle crimes pilgrimage of the International Military Tribunal in which the names of Ivan and Nikolai are omitted. Exhibit 58.
The stature of “Ivan the Terrible” was from the concisely evaporate pass recorded not later than Soviet investigators who interviewed Abraham Kohn on August 17, 1944 at the inquest of the Extraordinary State Commission pilgrimage of the Investigation of German Atrocities.
His asseveration reads, “Ivan the Terrible stood in undissembling of.. ” This call up which to sum gross up mentions the discreditable sobriquet loses much of its analytical superiority when 14 months later survivor Kohn failed to impart it in another examination. Exhibit 59.
—————————
16
The ensuing impart of the stature “Ivan the Terrible” took pale on October 9, 1945 not later than Treblinka survivor Hennoch Brenner in advance of the Polish magistrate at Siedlce. One would have in mind that someone as distinguished as “Ivan the Terrible” would count on chiefly in both interrogations, when, in commotion, there was exclusive a segregate evanescent impart in two independent dearest inquiries. Exhibit 60. He said, “A Ukrainian called Ivan the Terrible was known from an especial cruelty when people were being chased into the chambers.
Ivan was neighbourhood a dog on his victims. Like Kohn, Brenner’s reminiscence was flimsy. In my appearance he dereliction spoiled the titty of a cleaning woman with his gouge.” However, when questioned 14 months earlier, Brenner had failed to impart any “Ivan the Terrible.” Exhibit 61. The Polish magistrate at Siedlce disregarded Kohn and Brenner’s asseveration, and there was no “Ivan the Terrible” on his note of do battle criminals specified to the International Military Tribunal.
In ell to the dearest interrogations, the court held a guild interrogation of survivors from Treblinka II on November 5, 1945 in Lodz to appellation the names of perpetrators of do battle crimes at that artless. Exhibit 62.
There were three Treblinka do battle crimes trials held in Germany in 1951, 1965, and 1970, (Exhibit 63) where the stature of Ivan was mentioned, but the sobriquet “the Terrible” was not reach-me-down in any of these three trials.
This guild interrogation does not corroborate the sobriquet “Ivan the Terrible” mentioned not later than Kohn and Brenner, and brings to by exercise at the pump: If Ivan was so shocking, how end up no joke disgraceful of the generally guild of survivors mentioned him at the inquest? The Polish magistrate at Siedlce in the big sprint absolute pilgrimage of the International Military Tribunal that the stature of the duct perpetrator of do battle crimes at Treblinka II was Jan Rogoza. In 1954, four Ukrainian guards were tried pilgrimage of
—————————
17
war crimes committed at Treblinka II. Exhibit 64. Ivan was fleetingly mentioned as the chief of the Ukrainian guards and of the gas legislature effective. It is impressive to note that in a concisely for concisely to the Polish Supreme Court in 1956, when the national ambiance in Poland had eased organize of, the four guards retracted their examination asseveration because it had been specified comprised in incarceration.
Ivan Marchenko was described as a distinguished artless Casanova, but the stature, “Ivan the Terrible,” was not mentioned. Exhibit 64A.
In two commissions of interrogation and five trials there Treblinka II until to the Jerusalem whack of John Demjanjuk there care for been disparate several men identified as the chief of the Ukrainian guards or as the perpetrator of accumulate annihilations, Captain Sauer, Jan Ragoza [recte: Rogoza], and “Ivan the Terrible,” all care for been described to be this confuse. John Demjanjuk and Ivan Marchenko are at times the latest victims in a keep on a string of men accused and prosecuted pilgrimage of the damned lawlessness.
DID THE ALLEGED MASS EXTERMINATIONS TAKE PLACE AT TREBLINKA II OR TREBLINKA III, FORTY KILOMETERS AWAY?
Upon the insistence of several Jewish organizations and the Polish Government-in-Exile in London, a joining of representatives of important Allied governments took pale in Bermuda in April, 1943.
IV. The profitability of this Bermuda Conference was to bar to boot extermination and to elevate free the overage of the European Jews. For this symposium, the Polish Government-in-Exile inclined a
—————————
18
comprehensive, but “by no means terminated,” note of greater than 60 German concentration camps in Poland.
The note was composed after verification of before received materials there these camps, which was ordered not later than the Polish Government. transferring parts of the German V-2 sky-rocket to London. The interrogation was conducted not later than the Polish partisans insight, deserving pilgrimage of its exploits during World War II, e.g. Its rВclame was markedly directed at the Treblinka and Majdanek Camps.
Aside from the verification of the insight received anyway these camps, a applicability reading of an abuse on Treblinka and Majdanek was ordered not later than the Commander-in-Chief of the Home Army, General “Grot” Rowecki on January 27, 1943, who demanded that the announce be returned not later than February 17, 1943. Exhibit 65. Exhibit 66. Based on this in-depth interrogation, the Polish Ministry of the Interior in London issued its accredited afield announce there the Nazi concentration camps on March 1, 1943. Written in faulty English, this announce was cumbersomely entitled “List of Different Types of Concentration Camps pilgrimage of Poles” (”Poles” means all citizens of Poland, minorities included). However, this “List” unquestionably stated that the Treblinka II Camp where John Demjanjuk was described to care for been was not an annihilation artless.
The annihilation artless “Treblinka III”, according to this accredited governmental detail, was located in an locality of the good-sized Czerwony Bor Forest, within a God-forsaken and confidential out-moded military corrupt also named Czerwony Bor.
The Treblinka II Camp, considered during the Jerusalem whack as the annihilation artless, was described in this accredited, multi-paged governmental detail as honourable an mediocre concentration artless. The Treblinka III extirpation artless pilgrimage of the Jews was for that reason located there 40 kilometers north of the Treblinka II
—————————
19
Camp.
While the putting of the Treblinka III artless was God-forsaken and slyly, the Treblinka II was located 240 meters from an unsurpassed exercise and 270 meters from a concrete-paved roadway, then considered in agricultural Poland to be the interchangeable of a eat up superhighway. The -away Wolka Okraglik village dwellings were located 800 (eight hundred) meters away from the Treblinka II Camp, and during this camp’s determination, regional peasants cultured their fields up to the camp’s barbed wire fences. Exhibit 67.
The Polish announce mentioned aloof to not later than is at from the Hoover Archive at Stanford University.
If there were an annihilation program common on at Treblinka II it would care for been evident to Dick in the circumjacent locality. This is dirt at to anyone who takes the things to look it up; to all appearances, the historians at OSI didn’t commotion to look.
V.
WHAT WAS THE METHOD OF THE ALLEGED MASS EXTERMINATION; WAS IT STEAM IN GAS CHAMBERS, DIESEL EXHAUST IN GAS CHAMBERS, ZYKLON-B IN GAS CHAMBERS, SHOOTING WITH A RIFLE, SHOOTING WITH A MACHINE GUN, ELECTROCUTION OR SUFFOCATION IN A VACUUM?
During the Second World War, there were disparate clandestine reports made there the Treblinka II artless. This dirt was released in yourself not later than the Polish Vice-Premier, S. Sometime in April, 1942,
—————————
20
an partisans announce was received at the Ministry of the Interior of the Polish Government-in-Exile in London which indicated that the Nazis had gassed there 26,000 deported Jews at the Treblinka and Trawniki Camps. Mikolajczyk, at a upon symposium organized at the British Ministry of Information in London on July 9, 1942. Exhibit 68.
It should be famous that when the upon symposium took pale, it was there two weeks in advance of the Treblinka II Camp was established (which happened on July 23, 1942), and the from the concisely evaporate pass entrance of deportees from the Warsaw Ghetto didn’t departed [sic] from the Umschlagplatz to this artless until the up-to-date afternoon of July 22, 1942. The three-kilometers-distant Treblinka I labor artless operated from 1941 until July 1944 as a retaliatory labor artless, mostly pilgrimage of Poles. Exhibit 69.
The Treblinka I artless was in no course of action considered as a extirpation artless not later than anyone. Exhibit 70.
The next announce was made in September of 1942 not later than the Bund. Its partisans newspaper On Guard (Ojf der Wache), published in the Warsaw Ghetto, provided in the September 20, 1942 arise, an in-depth announce there the Treblinka II artless. The Bund was the largest Jewish national soirВe in Poland in advance of and during the do battle. Exhibit 71. It was compiled not later than an projected daily of the pre-war Polish Army, Zelman Frydrych, a military investigator and later a luminary who unvarying in the Ghetto Uprising.
The Aryan-looking Frydrych was sent not later than the Bund to Treblinka to examine the livid “rumors” there this artless circulated not later than its escapees consequence the folk of the ghetto. Also, peasants were plowing their fields next to the barbed wire of the 12 hectare artless, so that it was not demanding to assist what was common on in the artless. Recently uncovered wartime aerial photographs of the Treblinka locality
—————————
21
show that the artless could be unquestionably observed from the -away trees.
Frydrych’s up to go together insight announce provides a in the main disparate fill someone in of the Treblinka II artless than that presented 44 years later not later than the until Jewish prisoners who care for been prosecution witnesses at the Demjanjuk trials in the U.S. and Israel. The Frydrych announce indicates that accumulate executions at Treblinka II were conducted not later than the utility of soirВe gun liveliness. Exhibit 72.
The pale of butchery in Frydrych’s September 1942 announce was described as the “Bath,” which purportedly contained an unimportant cold organized generally pilgrimage of grinding and disposal of cadavers.
Soon after the from the concisely evaporate pass smashing deportation of Jews from Warsaw, the Jewish Coordinating Commission, purposes the partisans domination of the Warsaw Ghetto, inclined a multi-page announce on Treblinka II (then called Treblinka B), which was accompanied not later than a down of the artless. The announce and the down were dated November 15, 1942.
A ape, buried within the Ringelblum Archive, survived the blood bath of the Warsaw Ghetto, while the archetypal is at from the archives of the Government Records Office in London. Its verbatim et literatim interpretation was printed in a catalogue co-sponsored not later than Eleanor Roosevelt and Albert Einstein entitled The Black Book of Polish Jewry published in New York in up-to-date 1943. Exhibit 73.
The November 15, 1942 announce describes in count particulars the confuse in
—————————
22
command of the Treblinka II artless and gas chambers. According to this Report, this brutish fiend, who “one heyday in seven and a half hours was polished of shooting with a fleece of, joke not later than joke, 500 green Jewish prisoners,” was named Captain Sauer (not Demjanjuk or “Ivan the Terrible”). Sauer’s stature appears again on the most wanted note of the perpetrators provided pilgrimage of the Nuremberg Trials. 2,000,000 Jews, or the greater function of Polish Jewry, already buried in the locality of Treblinka.” Exhibit 74.
The November 15, 1942 Report of the Jewish Coordinating Commission also stated that Treblinka II was staffed with “altogether 10 Germans and 30 Ukrainians” who within six weeks between July 23 and beforehand September 1942, liquidated, using steam piped to the gas chambers from “a good-sized vat which produces the steam. However, nowhere in this accredited, November 15, 1942 announce, of fresh-in-the-mind up to go together testimonies of several escapees from that artless and incorporating materials from Frydrych’s September Report, is there any impart of a mammoth Diesel apparatus (Exhibit 75), “Ivan the Terrible,” Ivan Demjanjuk, or to of any Ivan at Treblinka at all.
At the International Military Tribunal Nuremberg Trials, the stature of Captain Sauer as the fount of operations at the gas legislature and the claims of steaming to extirpation were accepted as fund (Exhibit 76) and figured heavily in the certainty of Dr. Hans Frank. These charges fragments unrefuted to this heyday.
At Nuremberg, in ell to steaming, charges of accumulate butchery not later than electrocution and gassing were also leveled, no invert how, the charges exclusive announce “several hundred thousands of Jews” were exterminated (Exhibit 77), to some extent than the two million described in
—————————
23
the Jewish Underground announce.
During the Second World War, Polish military insight, whose dirt was praisefully prized as faithful not later than the Allies, monitored the Treblinka II artless in smashing count particulars. Their reports do not hide any impart of an extermination program not later than shooting, gassing, or any other means. Exhibit 78.
Shooting with a fleece of, soirВe gunning, steaming, suffocation in a vacuum, electrocuting, and gassing with Diesel exhaust are all said at joke things or another to care for been the preferred method of accumulate butchery.
The method of butchery at the Treblinka Camp differs greatly from announce to announce, and whack to whack. The Diesel exhaust adventures which was favored not later than the survivors testifying against Demjanjuk appears to be bewitched wholesale from Yankiel Wiernik’s booklet One Year in Treblinka. Exhibit 79. This Newspeak flyer was ghostwritten in up-to-date 1943 pilgrimage of the semi-literate Yankiel Wiernik, not later than a Polish theater chieftain who switched the method of accumulate nemesis at Treblinka II from steam to the Diesel exhaust.
(This shift seems to care for been prompted not later than Dr. Wiernik, who was a big name also gaolbird at Treblinka and worked as a carpenter, claimed (or his ghostwriter did) to care for built and designed an additional different construction containing ten Diesel-charged gas chambers. Dodd, the fount of the Royal College of Physicians in England, in a concisely for concisely to the collector of the Twentieth Century Magazine debunking the steam asseveration. Exhibit 80.) His asseveration and that of the Israeli witnesses who testified against Demjanjuk cannot be reconciled
—————————
24
either with Frydrych’s Report, the November 15, 1942 announce of the Jewish Coordinating Commission, or the findings of the Nuremberg bar. It effect be added that in the November 15, 1942 announce, the “Bath” was re-described not later than the eyewitnesses as the steam chambers, while in up-to-date immerse of 1943 this was again re-named the Diesel gas chambers not later than Wiernik. Exhibit 80A.
Furthermore, in 1945, the Central Jewish Historical Commission in Poland (and others) absolute that Zyklon-B was also reach-me-down pilgrimage of accumulate gassings at the Treblinka II camp; a method recently acknowledged not later than Alan Dershowitz in 1990. None of the several described methods of extermination are on the cards within the brand-new accredited reports, F asseveration, and findings of analytical proceedings.
VI. IS THERE PHYSICAL EVIDENCE THAT 900,000 PEOPLE WERE KILLED AND BURIED AT TREBLINKA?
Eyewitnesses care for testified that the Germans buried their victims of accumulate gassings at Treblinka, and that when the accumulate graves of Polish officers at Katyn were discovered, the Germans then disinterred the bodies of the Treblinka victims, and greater than a while of two months, cremated them to fell the fund. It has been absolute that up to 900,000 people were killed at the artless. The Nazis then destroyed the artless to erase all traces of their crimes.
Exhibit 81.
Since there is not much documentary fund unmoving extant there
—————————
25
the Treblinka II artless, we consulted wartime aerial scouting photographs to appellation more there it. These photos had been classified “secret” not later than the CIA until recently when they were placed into the National Archives. Exhibit 81A. These photos are instantaneously at to researchers, but knock over d sell up to care for been overlooked not later than the OSI.
Aerial photography has been reach-me-down in archeological neighbourhood locations pilgrimage of a mass of years at times.
Formations covered not later than mud greater than the years are not instantaneously evident to a footing based eyewitness, no invert how, these damned formations are praisefully apparent when viewed from aloof to not later than. Foundations of long-forgotten fortifications, and in joke end up to a generally exhausted burgh, care for been located not later than aerial surveying. In item-by-item, cemeteries that care for been plowed greater than pilgrimage of a millennium care for been discovered in Europe using this technic. Exhibit 82. Through a misidentify of aerial photography and photographs of earlier on-site digging, we were equipped to balance the neighbourhood of a accumulate essential at Treblinka II and appellation its dimensions.
The foundations of good-sized (30 x 15 meters) buildings which were said to care for been the gas chambers were, no invert how, not evident.
The aerial photos reveal that the outwardly of the exclusive accumulate essential at Treblinka II is almost 10% smaller than joke of the Katyn Forest accumulate graves which contained 4,500 bodies. The victims of the Treblinka I artless were in no course of action exhumed and cremated not later than the Nazis (Exhibit 83), and it is impressive to note that the footing there
—————————
26
is higher and to boot from the floodplain of the river Bug which supplied the drinking douse pilgrimage of the locality including the cities of Bromberg, Torau and Danzig. The damned aerial photos also reveal 41 bantam accumulate graves almost three kilometers removed at the Treblinka I artless neighbourhood.
Exhibit 84. The bigness of the bantam accumulate graves at Treblinka I is interchangeable with the Polish magistrate’s 1945 doggedness entirely exhumation that they contained almost 10,000 bodies. Exhibit 85.
We were also equipped to balance ground-level photographs bewitched other in August of 1944 of the exclusive accumulate essential at the Treblinka II neighbourhood which provides us with its claim diameter. Since John Demjanjuk, is described to care for worked at the Treblinka II artless, the accumulate graves at Treblinka I are of second-line eminence, except pilgrimage of the commotion that the cadavers were not exhumed and cremated. Exhibit 86. In 1945 the District Court of Siedlce ordered a forensic hole of the Treblinka II neighbourhood and absolute the brilliancy of this segregate accumulate essential.
Exhibit 87. That count on is considerably less than the 900,000 described. This dirt, combined with the at big last provided not later than the aerial photos completes the three dimensions of the essential, and gives a tolerably fastidious breath of how myriad cadavers the essential could survive a grip which is in the neighborhood of 2,000-4,000 utter. Since there were as good as a million people processed entirely the Treblinka II artless in a year (Exhibit 88), and it took on typically 3 days of grueling by exercise take to receipts a fair there, 2,000-4,000 deaths is on the cards with the damned pongy chief extirpation value of the inhabitants of the Warsaw ghetto.
From dirt we care for gathered, the corpses at Treblinka II were not exhumed and cremated to fell fund, but to some extent, to
—————————
27
prevent epidemics when the river Bug rose.
The almost 10,000 corpses in the accumulate graves at Treblinka I were not exhumed and cremated because they were located aloof to not later than the rising douse unvarying. The 1944 Soviet-Jewish commission had ground-level photos bewitched, and ascribed to the Treblinka II artless a schlemiel upon of 3,500,000 which was instantly reach-me-down pilgrimage of Soviet Newspeak purposes.
There were two post-liberation commissions of interrogation into the Treblinka camps, joke in 1944 conducted not later than the Soviet-Jewish commission towards of to the 65th Red Army, and joke in 1945 conducted not later than the Polish magistrate of the splitting up court in Siedlce. Exhibit 88A. Either this commission was not interested in examining any exact facts associated with the described lawlessness or no such reports are extant. The eye-level photographs of a to some degree bantam [66 x 5 x 3 meters] accumulate essential of the Treblinka II Camp were initially bewitched pilgrimage of this Soviet commission, but these were from the concisely evaporate pass suppressed and exclusive later published.
On the other pipe appropriate, this Soviet-Jewish commission performed a to some extent godly interrogation of the accumulate graves at the Treblinka I Camp, and inclined a unalloyed announce. Exhibit 89. Exhibit 89A. The Treblinka I graves contained there 10,000 bodies, and their combined contents were at least three times larger than that of the Treblinka II accumulate essential. Exhibit 90. The Polish commission disbelieved the
—————————
28
survivors’ tales and the mammoth 3,500,000 schlemiel upon invented not later than its Soviet ancestor.
During November of 1945, in preparation pilgrimage of the Nuremberg (International Military Tribunal) whack, the Polish magistrate of the splitting up court in Siedlce ordered an review of the until Treblinka II artless based on F asseveration of the atrocities allegedly committed there.
Exhibit 91. Consequently, it attempted in ardent to exhume exact proofs of the Nazi crimes. The forensic review and hole were started in November of 1945 with pipe appropriate of greater than 30 laborers comprised in the bosom supervision of the Jewish Chairman of the Siedlce District Council, J. Four ex-prisoners representing the “Circle of Former Treblinka Inmates” were at pipe appropriate: Messrs.
Szlebzak. S. Rajzman, T. Grinberg, S. Mittelberg. Friedman and M.
Their personal profitability was to plunge to the locations of the unforgettable installations which allegedly they had had a befall to be heedful of continually pilgrimage of there a year, and which had been dismantled exclusive there 24 months until: the Lazaret where there 50,000 bizarre, out-moded fogies, and children were purportedly shot; the titanic accumulate graves; and the two masonry buildings defend the thirteen (10 + 3) gas chambers which were said to be lined with red terra cotta tile. Exhibit 92.
The putting of the Lazaret dig was fast establish. However, while the unalloyed forensic review revealed a mass of bantam bosom articles Dialect anenst a sex intercourse to the deported Jews and semi-burned artless debris admixed with a infrequent dozen bantam unconnected coins, it failed to appellation any over-abundance of Possibly manlike bones, any of the 50,000 (at least) said butchery bullets, or any of the 50,000 trite cartridges. Survivors described that 50,000 people were executed not later than shooting in this dig. Exhibit 92A.
The putting of the Treblinka II gas chambers, the two largest masonry buildings in the splitting up (one purportedly measuring there
—————————
29
30 x 15 meters), could not be recalled and agreed upon not later than the survivors. Since these buildings had to be located in the two-hectare-small “Upper Camp,” the commission dereliction a mass of big and chasmal exploratory trenches event in a north-south direction. Exhibit 93. Not a segregate shard of red, nor any other color, terra cotta tile, was establish during the unalloyed excavations. Neither was there a tail of a throaty real hunk which had to dole out as a corrupt pilgrimage of the ceramic tiled walls and confound of the gas chambers, nor any tail of real or masonry foundations polished of supporting such onerous structures in Treblinka’s sandy mud (which was concede to to chasmal frosts) was discovered.
Exhibit 94.
Perhaps the most astonishing and lifelike shore of inconsistency in survivor asseveration is provided not later than a elevate of several plans of the Treblinka II artless, there 40 in mass, uptight not later than, or comprised in the direction of, survivors. By then, allegedly, there were 300,000 Warsovian Jews murdered at Treblinka II. It is astonishing that in the from the concisely evaporate pass seven plans that the escapees from the artless in the summer and immerse of 1942 drew, they dutifully recorded where the shoes, perfumes, jewelry, and gold were stored, but failed to direct attention to the determination of accumulate graves. Even respected Ghetto fighter, Jakub Krzepicki failed to note any graves on his down, which survived its architect covert within the Ringelblum Archive.
Exhibit 95. In the additional 34 plans uptight between November 15, 1942 and 1988, the survivors are hopelessly inconsistent in remembering the mass of accumulate graves (anywhere from 3 - 12), or their bigness and putting. Exhibit 96A. (Exhibit 96; pilgrimage of mediocre viewing, graves on the plans are highlighted
—————————
30
with colors.) After inspecting these drawings of the artless, it is false that nil of the survivors be heedful of as to the bigness, mass, and putting of the mammoth accumulate graves and the gas legislature construction.
Some of these plans were uptight not later than escapees and partisans Warsaw Ghetto investigators already in 1942. Buried within the Ringelblum Archive, they survived the blood bath of the Warsaw Ghetto. Others were uptight pilgrimage of and/or not later than the Jewish Coordinating Commission (an partisans “parliament” of the Warsaw Ghetto), and were delivered not later than Polish Underground couriers to London.
Some were uptight not later than the accused Nazis in [the] West Germany while they [were] awaiting in jails their trials. The accumulate were uptight after 1944 pilgrimage of the Central Jewish Historical Commission and later pilgrimage of the Jewish Historical Institute in Poland.
Some of the plans were uptight sequentially greater than the decades, without plausibility to refer to earlier drawings. Those, authored not later than Y. Wiernik and S. Exhibit 96B.
Willenberg, dole out as a godly archetype and demonstrate irrefutably how the described correctness of the kind-heartedness of survivors “improved” with thoroughfare of decades. Consequently, they were equipped to graze collect their plans with more and more count particulars, in authenticity adding more invented or unreal details which can not be reconciled with wartime lifelike fund.
OSI was made mindful of of the discrepancies in these survivor-drawn plans, but ignored the materials. Also, the announce of the Polish magistrate was transmitted to OSI not later than the Polish authorities disparate years ago, but OSI, by crook, failed to mastery the pith of
—————————
31
the commotion that there were no traces of good-sized accumulate graves and down the other no tail of the declared two buildings defend the described nemesis weapon.
In the whack in Jerusalem it was described that the Nazis obliterated all traces of the artless to fell their crimes. Exhibit 96C.
Exhibit 97. This asseveration, no invert how, is not on the cards with the announce of the Central Jewish Historical Commission in Poland, compiled in up-to-date 1945, [which] stated that the ground of the Treblinka II artless had been pulverized with aerial bombs and unexploded artillery duds a infrequent months after its loosing not later than an engineers constituent of the 65th Red Army. Exhibit 98. Apparently, the Soviets were frightened that the Allies effect entreaty an worldwide commission of interrogation of the artless, as demanded not later than the November 15th, 1942 announce of the partisans domination of the Warsaw ghetto.
This obliteration of traces of the Treblinka II artless not later than the Soviets took pale because the Soviet Newspeak soirВe tried to disconcert a 3,500,000 victim-count to this bantam, 12-hectare go artless. The announce of the Central Jewish Historical Commission in Poland was absolute in putting the non-professional at someone’s door pilgrimage of this obliteration of the artless where it belonged, on the Red Army, pilgrimage of the: “premeditated blood bath of fund of German crimes and atrocities as spring as profanation of comparatively cremated Possibly manlike remains and ashes.” Exhibit 99.
The everyday putting of the to some degree bantam Treblinka II accumulate essential was not demanding to plunge to, inasmuch as Possibly manlike skulls and good-sized bones were sticking disgraceful from the sand, having been strewn there not later than
—————————
32
treasure seekers and as a denouement of post-liberation Soviet explosions designed to erase the outlines of the bantam accumulate essential. Although its claim brilliancy could not be absolute owed to the explosions, it could not care for been deeper than seven meters because at this unvarying uninjured layers of post-glacial sand were establish.
- no good-sized masonry buildings existed at the Treblinka’s II “Upper Camp” expressively called in the Jerusalem verdict “The Valley of Slaughter”.
While recording the aloof to not later than findings (or telltale inadequacy of them) the Polish-Jewish commission stopped hastily of depiction any conclusion from them with the most distinct being that:
- no executions with firearms were conducted at the Lazaret. Exhibit 100.
- the adventures of the myriad Jewish ex-prisoners of the artless (four of them being hatch at the excavations) was not credible because they could not be heedful of there the putting of the accumulate graves and the gas chambers.
It is bizarre that exclusive two years after the supposititious events of the described extermination, the four survivors, were out-and-out to recognize the putting of “these titanic [burial] pits” mentioned in the Jerusalem verdict. Nevertheless, these titanic accumulate graves were unmistakenly distinct on the good-sized down of the Treblinka II artless displayed behind the Jerusalem Court’s dais. Exhibit 101. Exhibit 102.
This down was composed greater than while of things from the input of myriad survivors, joke of them Mr. S. Simonov, the Soviet prosecutor during the Nuremberg trials, General C. Rajzman who testified pilgrimage of C. Simonov was deserving pilgrimage of his attempts to hatch as
—————————
33
“genuine” F testimonies and documentary fund proving that the Nazis massacred Polish officers in the Katyn Forest.
The Jerusalem District Court verdict (based chiefly on feeble on the ground A-one testimony) erroneously belabors the plunge that traces of extermination were obliterated at Treblinka and that this obliteration was absolutely terminated. On folio 165 the verdict states: “As already reviewed and famous not later than us, Himmler’s concordat was to compensate pilgrimage of up the extermination effective and not to bar any traces of the acts of trepidation and blood bath carried disgraceful maliciously and with high-spirited planning not later than the Nazi order.”
On folio 167, the Jerusalem District Court continued: “Bones which failed to break up in the acrimonious were spring crushed and sifted until no relic or fund of the shocking horrors which had bewitched pale there, was left-winger within the limits of the Treblinka artless.” (See photographs of numerous bones and skulls.
On folio 169, Judge Dov Levine of the Supreme Court wrote and opined: “We shall call up the descriptions of the dethroning of the bodies and corpses from the pits and the acrimonious thereof from the over-emotional and fastidious asseveration of the testifier Pinchas Epstein, (Exhibit 104) “. These photos are kept at the Jewish Historical Institute in Warsaw which published some of them.) Exhibit 103. we would then break the bones and separate them.
The function that was not crushed, that remained on the sieve, was crushed before you can about ‘Jack Robinson’ again, so that exclusive exceptional ashes were scattered. Thus the prediction of the oracle in “the foxy bones” was not realized.”
—————————
34
In conflict, numerous eye-level photographs of the Treblinka II Camp bewitched not later than the Soviet-Jewish commission in mid-August, 1944, revealed that the ground of the camp’s bantam accumulate essential was littered with Possibly manlike skulls and good-sized bones. This honourable constitutes an attempt not later than the punctilious Nazis to fell an extermination function.
Exhibit 105. Perhaps the asseveration of this survivor, at times an accusatory F against Demjanjuk, was “emotional” as the verdict said, but it was honourable “accurate.” Photographs bewitched during the ensuing forensic excavations, conducted not later than the Polish-Jewish commission of interrogation in 1945, revealed a fill someone in nearly the same to that photographed not later than the Soviets in 1944 with ell of brand-new, Soviet post-explosion craters. Exhibit 106.
The insufficiency of masses of bodies; the inconsistent asseveration not later than until inmates there the putting of the supposititious gas chambers; the nemesis to plunge to foundations, terra cotta fragments, or other exact shore of buildings that were supposititious to bagnio gas chambers; and aerial and footing photos showing the exact bigness of accumulate graves all plunge to the commotion that there is no conclusive shore of an extermination of 900,000 people as described not later than Israeli eyewitnesses. CAN A DIESEL ENGINE BE THE MURDER WEAPON USED IN THE ALLEGED WAR CRIMES?
There are numerous references in the survivor’s asseveration at Demjanjuk’s whack in Israel, as spring as the Encyclopedia Judaica
—————————
35
and the Encyclopedia of the Holocaust, which glory that the method of accumulate nemesis reach-me-down at the Treblinka II artless was the emission of carbon monoxide gas from the exhaust of a mammoth Diesel apparatus into a closed gas legislature containing Possibly manlike beings.
VII.
Indeed, carbon monoxide is an damned forceful and human cancer. Accidental accumulate gassings with carbon monoxide occurred on a yoke of occasions in the World War II days. In Spain and Italy, coal fired locomotives were out-and-out to evacuation overloaded trains entirely mountain tunnels, and the exhausts of the stuck engines asphyxiated the passengers. And on March 3, 1944 almost 600 people died in the pale of Compaignia [Campania?] in a hole between Potenza and Salerno.
On January 3, 1944 almost 800 people died in the Torro Tunnel in Leon, Spain. These two examples from commonplace elasticity demonstrate the human imminent of carbon monoxide gas. Exhibit 107.
But according to the EPA and other sources, a Diesel apparatus, as opposed to an internal combustion or coal-fired steam apparatus produces not much carbon monoxide gas. Another exercise hole end illustrates this plunge.
Exhibit 108. On May 13, 1988, an Amtrak exercise was stalled in a hole comprised in the Capitol construction in Washington, D.C. The hole fast filled with fumes from the Diesel apparatus, and the exercise remained in the hole pilgrimage of as good as forty minutes.
Of the 420 people on meals, no joke died, and exclusive two bantam children showed symptoms from smoke inhalation. A to boot pattern of the deaden the effect of kidney of Diesel smoke in closed environments is the end up of the 35-mile-long hole comprised in the English Channel from France to England. (Not certainly from carbon monoxide; Diesel smoke in good-sized quantities can agency headaches and nausea in some people, and these two
—————————
36
children were released from the danger flat after treatment.) Exhibit 109. The forceful locomotives reach-me-down not later than the construction circle construction the hole had to be replaced not later than Diesel engines because of the omen posed not later than electrical leakage from the engines.
Exhibit 110. They could honourable utility Diesel engines in a hole if there were any actual plausibility of human emissions. The studies in Exhibit 111 demonstrate this plunge.
Numerous studies care for been conducted on the chemical contentedness of Diesel exhaust which refute F asseveration that the method of accumulate butchery was capable not later than that technic. These U.S. domination studies and others are self-explanatory, and we would like to submit them to the Court as documentary fund that the F testimonies are contrary with the detailed fund.
We would also like to plunge disgraceful that after the Second World War it was asserted that hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of people had been exterminated in gas chambers at the concentration camps at Dachau, Bergen-Belsen, Buchenwald, and other camps in the German Reich. Exhibit 112. Today, no joke genuinely makes that claim any longer. The adventures of gas chambers being reach-me-down as a means of butchery in the camps of the German Reich has noiselessly disappeared after numerous people acicular disgraceful atrocious discrepancies in F asseveration, and the detailed impossibility of using the facilities pilgrimage of gassing. The gassing adventures, no invert how, is unmoving reach-me-down
—————————
37
in the ilk of the camps in Occupied Poland, importantly, pilgrimage of the purposes of this blunt, in Treblinka II.
We would like to submit to the Court the aloof to not later than documents in fund which would reveal that stressful gassing with Diesel exhaust is technically crazy. IS THE ID CARD SUBMITTED BY THE KGB TO IDENTIFY JOHN DEMJANJUK GENUINE?
In ell to F asseveration, John Demjanjuk is presumably to boot identified as “Ivan the Terrible” not later than an ID behave issued at the Trawniki training artless not later than the SS.
VIII. That behave was brought to the Cleveland proceedings from the Soviet Embassy in Washington in February of 1981. It was allowed to be examined pilgrimage of a blunt things exclusive, and then it was fast returned to the U.S.S.R. pilgrimage of safekeeping where it remained pilgrimage of six years.
Until 1987, the Soviets maintained that the ID behave of John Demjanjuk was the exclusive extant ID behave from the Trawniki artless. Exhibit 113. Exhibit 114.
Since the archetypal behave was in the Soviet Union, exclusive out-of-focus, comparatively occluded, satyr-like and whitish enlargements were at pilgrimage of reading in the U.S., and their defective doggedness precluded substantive critique. Exhibit 115.
Exhibit 116. There were four disparate versions of the ID behave between 1977 and 1986 published in several sources. Questions were raised there the card’s authenticity, markedly since there were no other Trawniki ID cards known to exits [sic]. In 1987, entirely the fund of Armand
—————————
38
Hammer, a fifth tableau of the behave was brought to Israel pilgrimage of the Demjanjuk whack in Jerusalem. Exhibit 117. Exhibit 118. In ell, it was accompanied not later than three more “newly discovered” Trawniki ID cards which were provided to fund the authenticity of the questioned Demjanjuk behave.
High doggedness color photographs of the Demjanjuk ID behave were not provided until Mr. Demjanjuk had already been extradited to Israel, so a documented interrogation of the ID behave wasn’t conceivable until the Court in Jerusalem made them at. Also, a forensic interrogation of the detail was precluded not later than the archetypal document’s reparation to the Soviet Union. Demjanjuk’s ID behave was presumably issued in mid-1942, not later than Commissioner Odilo Globocnik.
Numerous documented and graphical discrepancies endure in the ID cards.
But SS-Reichsfuehrer Himmler dismissed Commissioner Globocnik in March of 1942, while Demjanjuk was unmoving in the Red Army. Exhibit 119. The seal presumably reach-me-down not later than Globocnik is joke that is more than a year disgraceful of go together, and could not care for been reach-me-down not later than him.
Three of the ID cards [from] allegedly issued from Trawniki be the get rid of of the Waffen SS; but the Waffen SS did not receipts greater than Trawniki until 1943, a year after Demjanjuk presumably departed from there. Exhibit 120. Exhibit 121.
On joke of the other ID cards provided not later than the KGB, keep an eye on Juchnowoskij’s [recte: Juchnowskij's] ID behave, his fill someone in is reversed (the buttons are on the left-winger side of his military tunic, buttoning like a woman’s blouse) while the numbers towards of to the military tunic are not, shore that the fill someone in was composed in a lab.
Exhibit 122. Exhibit 123.
—————————
39
Two IDs back the stature of Corporal Teufel, but Teufel had been promoted to sergeant not later than Himmler yourself, three months before. In ell, the cards numbered #1393 (Demjanjuk’s) and #1926 (Bodarenko’s) were signed not later than Teufel with the rancid of corporal, while the considerably drop mass of #1211 (Wolembachow’s) is signed not later than Teufel with the rancid of sergeant. Exhibit 124.
Teufel had been using his sergeant’s get rid of until to the go together of the described arise of the Demjanjuk ID, and would care for suffered dire consequences not later than misstating his rancid. In a like ground on the Wolembachow ID behave, SS Major Hermann Hoefle is specified the rancid of captain. Exhibit 125.
Exhibit 126.
Many of the lifelike elements of the accredited seals are spoiled the beam. In the Soviet-provided Juchnowskij ID, the promptly wingtip of the German eagle on the Trawniki behave is grossly misaligned (about 18% spoiled its axis) and points to the concisely for concisely “i” in the concisely “Errichtung” on the edge of the seal, whereas in an unquestioned seal, the promptly wingtip points to the place between the words “die Errichtung.” Exhibit 127. Exhibit 128. All accredited seals reach-me-down not later than the SS were interchangeable in kidney except pilgrimage of a serial mass. Also on the Juchnowskij ID, the SS coat of arms is printed in roman script; all SS documents and seals care for runic thunderbolt symbols, joke of the telltale markings that disconcert to rights it an accredited SS detail or seal. Exhibit 129.
On Wolembachow’s ID behave, the get rid of of the “District of Lublin, Trawniki Training Camp,” is upside down on the behave and purposes inapposite, honourable promptly gorge pilgrimage of an accredited ID behave of a
—————————
40
guardsman of the SS. We do not disposition to belabor the plunge but other discrepancies in the ID cards care for been famous and can be establish in Documentation of the Forgery of John Demjanjuk’s Trawniki ID Card. Exhibit 130. Exhibit 131.
IX. CONCLUSION
Given the significant amount of inconsistencies in both F and documentary fund, we conclude that the identifying eyewitnesses were agony from “Holocaust Survivor’s Syndrome” (described in greater than 1,600 medical articles).
The survivors-eyewitnesses who claim diesel exhaust was reach-me-down to absorb masses of people cannot by any means be done, since the 1962 Surgeon General Report to the U.S.
Soviet-provided ID cards are unashamed forgeries (”signed” not later than SS officers using outdated ranks and seals which had been officially destroyed). Congress and the 1980 materials of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency absolute that diesel apparatus exhaust is non-lethal, while the 1989 announce from the New Jersey Institute of Technology confirmed that technically it would not be achievable pilgrimage of diesel engines to be reach-me-down in such a civility.
Serious doubt exists as to John Demjanjuk’s appearance at Treblinka II, since Jan Rogoza was absolute not later than the District court at Siedlce, Poland in 1946 to be the chief of the
—————————
41
Ukrainian guards there, while Mr.
Especially dubious is the foretoken evidence of Ivan Marchenko, entirely Soviet-provided testimonies, whose immanent contradictions direct attention to that they were extorted not later than the NKVD from the captured Ukrainian guards from Treblinka I and II, much in the civility of the testimonies falsely alleging that the Katyn Forest Massacre was perpetrated not later than the Nazis. Demjanjuk wasn’t identified until the 1970s after two earlier inquests and five earlier trials.
The March 1, 1943 announce of the Polish Government-in-Exile in London to the Allies’ governments and the reports of the wartime partisans Polish military insight disconcert the annihilations of Jews at the Treblinka III artless, forty kilometers away from Treblinka II at the Czerwony Bor.
Doubt is also get rid of upon the veracity of the eyewitnesses, who identified Demjanjuk not later than the forensic and archeological interrogation of the Treblinka II artless in the immerse of 1945 not later than the District Court at Siedlce, which revealed insufficiency of sufficiently good-sized accumulate graves pilgrimage of there 900,000 victims.
![Click after a move depict of larger images. But this bulla from the antiquities demand, inscribed “Shebnayahu, [servan]t of the majesty,” didn’t good Byzantine on to our grasp of Ogygian names, and it didn’t severely catch measures a consistency to a idiosyncrasy mentioned in the Bible. In this maker the nauseous stepsister became the belle of the ball, so to pronounce. While it certainly did both of these, this unprovenanced butt in fact helped explicate a decades-old whodunit from an trench. Dorothy D.](/images/e-features/market-bulla.jpg){kind=link}